United Kingdom Puccini, Tosca: Soloists, Refrain and Orchestra of the Royal Opera Home / Andrea Battistoni (conductor). Royal Opera Home, Covent Backyard, London, 14.7.2023. (JPr)
Manufacturing:
Director – Jonathan Kent
Revival director – Peter Relton
Designer – Paul Brown
Lighting designer – Mark Henderson
Refrain director – William Spaulding
Forged:
Angelotti – Germán E. Alcántara
Sacristan – Jeremy White
Cavaradossi – Yusif Eyvazov
Tosca – Sonya Yoncheva
Baron Scarpia – Aleksei Isaev
Spoletta – Hubert Francis
Sciarrone – Jamie Woollard
Gaoler – John Morrissey
Younger Shepherd – Madeleine McGhee
British director Jonathan Kent had a tough act to observe when creating a brand new Tosca manufacturing after 4 many years of the legendary Franco Zeffirelli one which had returned repeatedly to Covent Backyard and racked up a complete of 242 performances. On the time Kent commented how ‘Every technology has to reinvent these classics or they develop into museum items’. The whole for Kent’s Tosca have to be fairly spectacular by now too and there are extra performances to return subsequent season when Sonya Yoncheva, making her position debut right here as Tosca, sings Puccini’s diva once more.
I noticed the Zeffirelli Tosca many instances from 1980 (with Shirley Verrett within the title position) and Kent’s many instances too since 2006 and I believed it could be fascinating to go proper again and see what I wrote then. Eighteen years in the past, I thought-about it a triumph of substance over fashion and one thing I’d have anticipated to see – magnified about thrice – on the amphitheatre in Verona; particularly Paul Brown’s arching staircase which might dwarf the singers there nearly as a lot because it does at Covent Backyard. In the meantime Brown’s costumes seemed again to Zeffirelli reasonably than carry something new to Kent’s model. In Act I there’s nonetheless loads of clambering up a ladder to the platform the place Cavaradossi is working and Yusif Eyvazov – additionally making a job debut – didn’t appear to benefit from the expertise a lot. Additionally, there are the hasty entrances from the again of a split-level stage to get to the highest of the staircase in time, adopted by all of the strolling up and down the steps, all undermining Tosca and Scarpia’s entrances.
I nonetheless suppose the primary act set, utilized in a sure approach, would have made for a splendidly intimate setting for Act II. Singers had already been thrust to the entrance of the stage with their voices thrown ahead by a semi-circular church set. This was much more noticeable on this event as I feel this July matinee Tosca was the loudest I’ve ever heard. Not in a foul approach, fairly the opposite, it was thrilling stuff of the kind I’ve not heard at Covent Backyard for a while: not that I’m there as a lot as I was. In Act II there’s a monumental library with a big central statue of a legendary determine with a sword. Plenty of candlesticks after all, together with two handily positioned side-by-side on what appeared surprisingly, amongst this opulence, to seem like a trestle-table for Scarpia to eat his meal off.
Within the third act the stage opened up and there’s a new vista with a long-curved wall, 4 execution posts throughout the entrance of the stage and we see the gaoler at his ablutions. Cavaradossi sings his reflective aria in murky mild; the lighting by Mark Henderson continues to be not one among this manufacturing’s strengths. Too usually – and particularly when a star singer brings her personal costumes – Tosca emerges sporting one thing fully completely different from Act II, as if she had gone garments buying. Fortunately right here – and serving to make it extra dramatically credible – Tosca was in the identical elegant sliver-grey robe.
The musical values of this Tosca will need to have been on an all-time excessive for current seasons at Covent Backyard as a result of hardly ever have I seen the casting for verismo-fashion operas with two (or three right here perhaps?) exceptionally proficient singers on the high of their kind. There may be an argument to recommend the principal singers simply stuffed their lungs and sang forte on a regular basis when a bit extra subtlety wouldn’t have come amiss. However would I’ve wished to have seen and heard it some other approach when it was completed, no I wouldn’t, like all of the others becoming a member of within the big ovation the forged acquired.
Any sense that debutant – and welcome again anytime – Andrea Battistoni might need some other consideration for this opera than as a can belto one have been dismissed as quickly as he allowed the iron-lunged Yusif Eyvazov to hold on to his high C of ‘Vittoria! Vittoria!’ past all expectations. What a pleasure it was to have Eyvazov verify how – as I’ve believed from a number of current streamed performances – he is likely one of the main dramatic tenors of this technology. ‘E lucevan le stelle’, though full-throated, was phrased superbly with simply the correct quantity of despair and remorse. Eyvazov sung his ode about Tosca’s darkish eyes with an actual sense of poetry and there was nice chemistry between him and Yoncheva which appeared to result in this Cavaradossi and Tosca being extra affectionate than we generally see, Madonna or no Madonna. As soon as once more on the finish Cavaradossi goes together with Tosca’s plans to flee with out believing it’s going to succeed. Eyvazov’s appearing was completely credible all through with out there being any alternative for the successful smile he revealed at his curtain name.
Sonya Yoncheva as Tosca performed the position of the standard diva to perfection particularly when enacting all her character’s insecurities and jealousy in Act I. Her ‘Vissi d’arte’ was a deeply touching prayer and sung with appreciable sorrow about her plight. The stabbing was impressively staged together with her vehemence (she spat out Tosca’s phrases ‘E avanti a lui tremava tutta Roma!’) as affecting and efficient as her forgiveness for the vile seducer Scarpia as she removes the crucifix from her neck and locations it on his corpse with these two candles both aspect of him.
Aleksei Isaev’s venal Scarpia was a black-hearted villain to the core, and he had a really darkish baritone sound. Right here he seemed to be a remorseless sadist whose different ‘ardour’ is to drive ladies to do his bidding and Isaev introduced little of the air of civility – we all know is barely pretence – which some singers carry to the position. Isaev completely deserved the gentle pantomime-style booing he bought from some within the viewers! For me, he might need made just a bit extra of the Italian phrases than he did, however it was a memorable portrayal nonetheless.
A superb ensemble noticed splendid vignettes from Germán E. Alcántara’s fleeing Angelotti, Jeremy White’s fussy Sacristan, Hubert Francis’s compliant Spoletta and Madeleine McGhee’s plaintive Younger Shepherd.
From the best way the orchestra performed for Battistoni you would by no means think about they have been in the course of a long term of Toscas as they sounded recent, vivid and thrilling from the second the conductor threw his arms within the air for the doom-laden begin with its opening Scarpia chords. From then on it was as if the musicians had been let of a leash and there was all the phobia and fervour you anticipate from Puccini’s ‘shabby little shocker’.
All in all, it was an old school, grand Italian night time – nicely afternoon! – on the opera, one thing I had nearly given up hope of ever being at once more
Jim Pritchard
